JJ McCarthy Giants Debut: New York Bring QB In Second Half vs Commanders After Jameis Winston Struggles In NFL Week 5

J.J. McCarthy had an opportunity in the second half of the New York Giants’ NFL Week 5 game against the Washington Commanders on Sunday, October 11, 2026. The Giants turned to the quarterback after a disappointing first-half offensive display, with Jameis Winston struggling to move the ball consistently as New York trailed 12-3 at halftime.

McCarthy, acquired from the Minnesota Vikings less than two weeks ago, had already made a brief appearance in the first quarter. His second-half opportunity could give the Giants a chance to spark their offence and change the momentum against their NFC East rivals.

JJ McCarthy Giants Debut Against Commanders

The Giants entered the game with Winston as their starting quarterback and McCarthy as his backup. However, New York managed just 70 total yards in the first half, prompting questions about whether the coaching staff should give McCarthy a longer look.